ARTICLES
- Home
- Articles
Progressive Islam: Contestation of Islamic Thought in Indonesia
Progressive Islam in Indonesia did not emerge in a vacuum; it is the result of a long process involving various interactions between Islam, local culture, and global influences.
Introduction
Indonesia, with the largest Muslim population in the world, has become a fertile ground for the development of various forms of Islamic thought. In this context, the emergence of the idea of “Progressive Islam” is an interesting phenomenon to study.
This idea not only reflects the intellectual dynamics that are developing among Indonesian Muslims, but also shows how Muslims are trying to answer the challenges of the times within the framework of a rich and diverse religious tradition.
In this article, I will examine Progressive Islam in depth, including how this idea emerged, developed, and how it is viewed and contested within the spectrum of other Islamic thought in Indonesia.
What is Progressive Islam?
Progressive Islam, in a general sense, refers to an approach to Islam that seeks to integrate progressive values such as gender equality, social justice, democracy, and human rights, into the religious understanding and practice. This thinking does not see Islam as a religion that is static and closed to change; instead, Islam is seen as a dynamic religion, which is able to adapt to the development of the times without losing its essence.
Progressive Islam is often considered as an answer to conservative or traditional Islam which tends to maintain a rigid religious interpretation and is not open to change. Progressive Islamic thinkers in Indonesia try to reinterpret holy texts with a contextual approach, where they take into consideration the social, political, and cultural situations in the interpretative process.
Progressive Islam in Indonesia did not emerge in a vacuum; it is the result of a long process involving various interactions between Islam, local culture, and global influences. The history of the development of Islam in Indonesia itself has shown diversity in the way Muslims interpret their religious teachings. From the time of the Nine Saints (wali songo) who brought Islam to Java, to the reformist movement of the early 20th century, Islamic thought in Indonesia has always been in a contestation between those who want to maintain tradition and those who try to respond to new challenges.
The post-independence era of Indonesia was an important moment for the development of Islamic thought. In the 1950s to 1960s, a number of Islamic figures and movements emerged who tried to offer religious interpretations that were more relevant to the Indonesian national situation. This thinking was influenced by political dynamics, such as the relationship between Islam and the state, as well as the need to respond to global ideologies such as communism and capitalism.
During the New Order period under President Suharto, Islamic discourse was mostly silenced or controlled by the state. However, in the Reformation era after the fall of Suharto, there was an extraordinary revival of Islamic intellectuals. It was during this period that Progressive Islam began to gain a significant place in religious discourse in Indonesia. This thinking was widely developed by young intellectuals who had learned from the intellectual traditionsof Islam in the Middle East, as well as progressive thinkers from the West.
A number of figures and movements played key roles in the development of Progressive Islam in Indonesia. One of the most prominent was Abdurrahman Wahid (affectionately known as Gus Dur), the former President of Indonesia and leader of Nahdlatul Ulama (NU). Gus Dur was known as a thinker who dared to offer an inclusive and tolerant religious interpretation, especially on issues related to minorities, pluralism, and human rights. His thinking is heavily influenced by classical Islamic scholarly traditions, but with a very contextual approach.
In addition to Gus Dur, there is also Nurcholish Madjid, or who is familiarly called Cak Nur. Cak Nur is an intellectual figure who became a pioneer of modern Islamic thought in Indonesia. Previously in 1970, he was known for the idea of “Islam Yes, Islamic Party No”, which emphasised that Islam should be a universal value that transcends political barriers. Cak Nur’s ideas are heavily influenced by philosophical and sociological thinking from the Western world, but he remains firmly rooted in the Islamic tradition.
On the other hand, there are also more collective movements, such as the Liberal Islam Network (JIL) founded by UlilAbshar Abdalla. JIL openly carries progressive and liberal forms of Islamic thought, emphasising the importance of reinterpreting the sacred texts and the relevance of Islam in responding to contemporary issues such as democracy, pluralism, and individual rights.
Criticisms against Progressive Islam
Although Progressive Islam has received a lot of support, especially from intellectuals and young people, it has not escaped criticism.
Conservatives often accuse Progressive Islamic thinkers of being too influenced by Western ideas that are considered inconsistent with Islamic teachings. They reject ideas such as gender equality in Islam.
Another criticism comes from traditionalist Islamic groups who see Progressive Islam as an attempt to weaken the authority of the ulama and traditional religious institutions. They argue that religious interpretations should not be left to individuals, especially those who do not have adequate religious education.
In the context of politics, Progressive Islam is also often accused as a tool to weaken the political position of Islam itself. Islamist groups criticise Islamic progressive thought as a form of ‘disguised secularism’ that seeks to separate Islam from the public and political life.
Contestation of Progressive Islam vs Conservative Islam
The contestation between Progressive Islam and Conservative Islam is one of the most striking dynamics in religious discourse in Indonesia today. This battle is not only taking place in the intellectual realm, but also in the political and social realms. Conservative Islam, which is often represented by Islamic movements such as the Islamic Defenders Front (FPI) or Hizbut Tahrir Indonesia (HTI), emphasises the importance of implementing shari’a (Islamic law) literally and rejects the contextual interpretation proposed by Progressive groups.
Conservative Islam in Indonesia tends to have a strong influence at the grassroots level, especially through religious studies, Islamic boarding schools, and Islamic missionary institutions. They often use rhetoric that exploits fears of “moral decadence” or “foreign cultural attacks” to attract mass support. On the other hand, Progressive Islam is more dominant among intellectuals, academics, and the urban middle class who tend to be more receptive to new ideas.
The debate has also spread to social media, where both groups argue and try to shape public opinion. Social media has become a new arena for the spread of Islamic thought, where both Progressive and Conservative Islam seek to expand their influence.
Challenges Ahead
Progressive Islam in Indonesia cannot be separated from global influences. This thinking is inspired by similar movements in other Islamic worlds, such as the Muslim feminist movement in the Middle East, or liberal Islamic thinkers in Iran and Egypt. However, the biggest challenge for Progressive Islam in Indonesia is how it can remain relevant and gain wider acceptance among Muslims, especially amidst the increasingly complex currents of globalisation.
Another challenge faced by Progressive Islam is how to provide answers to contemporary issues such as the environment, technology, and the economy that are increasingly pressing. Progressive Islamic thinkers must be able to offer solutions that are not only in accordance with Islamic values, but also relevant to the needs of the times.
On the other hand, the sustainability of Progressive Islam in Indonesia also depends heavily on the success of its supporters in building educational and missionising (dakwah)institutions that can strengthen the spread of this thought. Without strong institutional support, Progressive Islam risks becoming only an elitist intellectual discourse and is unable to reach wider levels of society.
Therefore, Progressive Islam is one of the currents of thought that plays an important role in the religious dynamics ofIndonesia. Despite facing many challenges, both from conservative circles and internal challenges, this thought offers a fresh and relevant perspective in dealing with contemporary issues. By continuing to develop itself, Progressive Islam has the potential to become one of the intellectual forces that can bring Indonesian Islam to a more inclusive, tolerant, and just direction.
The contestation of Islamic thought in Indonesia, between the progressive and conservative, is a reflection of the dynamic democratic process in religious life in this country. In this process, Progressive Islamic thought may continue to be tested by time, but it also has the potential to be a catalyst for the renewal and revitalisation of Islamic thought that is more in line with the spirit of the times.
Islamic thought in Indonesia will continue to develop along with the social, political, and cultural changes that occur. And in this respect, Progressive Islam has a very significant role: as a bridge between tradition and modernity, between text and context, and between Islamic values and the ever-changing global challenges.
References
Allport, Gordon W. (1955), The Nature of Prejudice, Cambridge, Mass.: Addison-Wesley Pub. Co.; Boston: Beacon Press
Newcomb, Theodore M. (1952), Social Psychology, London: Tavistock Publications
Budhy Munawar-Rachman
Dr Budhy Munawar-Rachman is a Lecturer at the Driyarkara College of Philosophy (STF) in Jakarta, Indonesia.